The Indians, the Chiefs, the Redskins and the Braves are all references to Native Americans. They’re also all sports teams.
It has been a longstanding argument whether or not the athletic world should allow Native American names to double as teams’ names. Many say that it is racist and offensive to make a group of people into a sports logo.
They say that America needs to remember to be inclusive in everything it does and not name sports teams after specific people groups. They argue that names like the Chiefs, Indians, Redskins and Braves are exclusive and stereotypical.
The problem with this argument is, generally, people only have a problem with the Native American-related teams. What about the Yankees, Cowboys, Vikings, Patriots, Raiders and Fighting Irish to name a few?
These other teams are all also groups of people. The Yankees, a term that originated during the Civl War era, are northerners, a group that I am a part of. Yet the term doesn’t offend me in the least bit.
Based on what I‘ve observed, the Irish are extremely proud to support Notre Dame, not offended by the mascot. I’ve also never heard of a cowboy complaining that a sports team is named after and stereotypes his profession. Not that I know any professional cowboys, but still.
Rather than looking at these names as offensive, we need to appreciate the historical and cultural value they hold.
I don’t think the names for these teams were selected with any malicious intent or desire to offend. It’s when people over-analyze that we have a problem. Besides, changing the name of the team takes away so much.
No one wants to wear their T-shirts and keep paraphernalia for a team that doesn’t even exist anymore. A team name is part of a team’s heritage, and there’s really no purpose in changing it.
So instead of criticizing team’s mascots, just appreciate them for what they represent.
I have to agree with what Steven Denson, director of diversity for Southern Methodist University and member of the Chickasaw nation, said: “I believe it is acceptable if used in a way that fosters understanding and increased positive awareness of the Native-American culture. And it must also be done with the support of the Native-American community.”
Unless the people who a team is representing have issue with the logo, there shouldn’t be a problem. I know that I for one would much rather be called something like a Redskin or a Brave than a Pelican or a Wizard.
